The NBN is broken. Here’s the fix.

Main Article Content

Phil Dobbie


Telecommunications, Economics, NBN, cross-subsidy


The approach to the NBN has been fated from the beginning. This paper explores how the original design was more to do with constraining Telstra’s monopolistic ambitions than developing a sensible broadband policy for Australia. The result is a solution that is expensive, constrains competition, is blighted by Telstra’s infrastructure – including the widespread use of asbestos – with a one-size fits all approach that satisfies few. The ambition of ubiquity is also examined. How can it be ubiquitous if many people choose not to subscribe?

With the optimistic air of change that has come from a new Prime Minister, this is the time to look at a realistic option that accepts the approach will include government on-budget expenditure, establishes a future proof approach and provides the opportunity for those who want it to pay a realistic amount towards getting connected. The analogy is, governments build roads, not driveways. So why should we assume anyone building a national telecommunications network should worry about connecting right up to the front door, especially for those who don’t want it.

Abstract 407 | PDF Downloads 3


ABS (2015), Average Weekly Earnings, Australia, May 2015. Retrieved from

Akamai (2015), The State of the Internet Report. Retrieved from

Broadband Commission for Digital Development (2014). Open Letter from the Broadband Commission for Digital Development to the ITU Plenipotentiary Conference 2014.Retrieved from

Commonwealth of Australia (2014), Budget 2014-15. Building Australia’s Infrastructure. Appendix B. Retrieved from

Department of Communications (2014). Independent Cost-Benefit Analysis of the NBN. Retrieved from

Dobbie, P (2009), The Economics of the NBN. Retrieved from

Dobbie, P (2009), Special edition Telstra break-up podcast. Retrieved from

Dobbie, P (2011), By the Numbers: BT Predicts Telstra’s Future? Retrieved from

Dobbie, P (2012), Up to Speed: Small Towns Quick to Download. Retrieved from

Dobbie, P (2013), Will the NBN Fix a Broadband Availability Gap? Retrieved from

Dobbie, P (2013), A Cheaper Way to Roll Out Faster Broadband. Retrieved from

Eden District Council (2015), Profile of Eden. Retrieved from

NBN (2012), Corporate Plan 2012-15. Retrieved from

NBN (2015), Corporate Plan 2016. Retrieved from

NBN (2015), Price List. Wholesale Broadband Agreement. Retrieved from

OECD (2014), Fixed Broadband Subscription Price Ranges. Retrieved from

OECD (2014), OECD Fixed Broadband Subscriptions per 100 Inhabitants, by Technology, December 2014. Retrieved from

Osborne (2014), The Second Machine Age. Retrieved from

Telstra (2015), Telstra Fact Sheet: general Asbestos Information. Retrieved from

Wikileaks (2015), Secret Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement (TPP) Treaty: State-Owned Enterprises (SOE) Issues for Ministerial Guidance. Retrieved from

Wikipedia (2015), List of Countries by Population Density. Retrieved from

Wilton (2015). “FTTB race on as TPG passes 350 MDUs” Communications Day September 9, 2105